Is human nature originally good or evil mencius hsun tzu views

He thinks punishments will still be necessary because some people will break the law, but a sage king will only rarely need to employ punishments to keep the people in line, while a lord-protector or ordinary ruler will have to resort to them much more.

It was only through practice that one could realize the beauty of ritual, ideally coming to appreciate it for itself.

mencius and hsun tzu are fundamentally concerned with:

Whereas Mencius claimed that man is born with an inclination to do good, Kao Tzu believed that all of mankind is born morally neutral. Heaven does not reward good kings with peace and prosperity, nor punish tyrants by having them deposed.

The political thinkers of the time instead tried to impose checks through tradition and thought, rather than law. Ivanhoe, eds. Xunzi views these achievements as products of the sage's acquired nature, not his original nature.

His beliefs fell between the difference of nature and morality.

mencius human nature

The chief function of language is to communicate, and anything that interferes with communication, such as the word games and paradoxes of other philosophers, should be eliminated. According to one story, a philosopher, having just convinced a king through his arguments, then took the other side and persuaded the king that his earlier arguments were wrong.

Is human nature originally good or evil mencius hsun tzu views

Desires are part of human nature, and can be activated without our necessarily being conscious of them. Yet the rationalism, religious skepticismconcern for man in society, historical and cultural sensitivity, and fondness for ancient lore and customs that pervade his writings also pervaded Chinese intellectual life for more than two millennia.

Today, he is still considered to be the second most important figure in Confucianism, with Confucius himself being the most important.

Xunzi vs mencius

In fact, Xunzi believes people do not enjoy it at all, which is why they desire the kind of life that results from good order brought about through the rituals of the sages. Mencius suggested that all men are born good and, that with time and proper training, can become perfect. What people can do is decide whether to act on a desire or not. The beginning student of ritual is like a child learning to play the piano. Not only will this result in order and stability, it actually will allow for greater satisfaction of everyone's desires than the competition of the state of nature. Yao reformed his original nature, Jie did not. This concept of moral power was quite old in China even in Xunzi's time, though initially it referred to the power gained from the spirits through sacrifice. By nature we all desire the same things: fine food, beautiful clothing, wealth, and comfort.
Rated 6/10 based on 75 review
Opposing Views